1. Home
  2. Buffalo, NY
  3. Personal Injury
  4. The Nicotra Law Firm, PC

The Nicotra Law Firm, PC

ListedPersonal InjuryBuffalo, NY● Accepting new clients
★★★★★ 4.9 · 334 Google reviews3 offices0 attorneysEnglish
Not statedFee model
FreeInitial consultation
1Practice areas

About The Nicotra Law Firm

The Nicotra Law Firm, PC is a personal injury firm with offices in Buffalo, Rochester and Canandaigua.

The firm states that the first consultation is free. It does not state a fee model on its public pages, so none is recorded here.

What this firm has earned Every one from a measured value, with the evidence behind it

334 client reviews

Counted across 3 verified Google Business Profile listings, not collected by us and not solicited through us.

4.92 average over 334 reviews

A high rating is easy at low volume and hard to hold at this one. Pillar C scores it against the market rather than against five stars.

LFL Certification Score Scored under Methodology v2.0 · rows tagged Registry, Observed or Ahrefs are measured; rows tagged Illustrative are sample values pending full verification

37out of 100
LFL Certification Score · Methodology v2.0Scored across 78 of the 100 points this firm's state lets anyone measure. Anything unscored counts neither for nor against the firm.

Listed

1 eligibility gate(s) still to be checked. Certification needs more of the scale measured than we have managed here, pillar A in particular. Strongest pillar: C; most headroom in pillar B (0/15).

Certified needs more measured
70 needed · A+B+C floor not yet met (58% of the A, B and C points assessed)
Most headroom: A2 Experience: not yet measured (10 pts) · A6 Roster verifiability: not yet measured (9 pts) · B1 Results published: +6 available
G1 LicensureNo attorneys publishedThis firm names no attorney on its public pages, so there is no roster whose licensure can be checked. The register is open and free to search; the names are what is missing.
G2 DisciplineNo attorneys publishedThis firm names no attorney on its public pages, so there is no roster whose disciplinary history can be checked. The register is open and free to search; the names are what is missing.
G3 Entity & officeTHE NICOTRA LAW FIRM, P.C. is an active domestic professional service corporation registered since 2023-11-16, with 3 Google-verified locations
G5 WebsiteNot checkedSite has served over HTTPS, a working phone number published, no attorney is named on the site we could read. The gate also asks for no misleading claims, which is an editorial read we have not recorded.
G6 Footprint334 public client reviews and 3 years since the entity was formed in 2023
Professional Standing
3/25
A2 ExperiencePendingNot yet assessed0 / 10
A6 Roster verifiabilityPendingNo attorney is named on the site we could read0 / 9
A5 AccountabilityObservedmember of New York State Trial Lawyers Association · no professional liability cover disclosed, which is not scored here: plaintiff firms in this market do not publish it, and an absence shared by every firm separates none of them3 / 3
BPublished Outcomes
0/15
B1 Results publishedFirm-submittedThe firm publishes no case results we could read0 / 6
B2 SpecificityFirm-submitted0 case types named; no court or county named, so no result can be looked up0 / 5
B3 Results disclosureFirm-submittedNo prior-results disclaimer on the results page, which the New York advertising rules effectively require0 / 4
CClient Experience
19/20
C1 Authentic volumeObserved334 Google reviews · Google Business Profile via Places API. 3 listings, counts summed and rating weighted by count5 / 5
C2 Rating qualityObservedGoogle rating 4.92 over 334 reviews → Bayesian 4.90 (prior 4.82 weighted as 100 reviews, from 217 scored firms) · single platform, Google only5 / 6
C3 Review recencyGoogle14 of 14 sampled reviews are from the last 12 months (newest 2026-09-11) · a sample of five per business listing, not every review5 / 5
C5 Complaint shareGoogle0 of 14 sampled reviews rate 1 or 2 stars · a sample, so this is the shape of the complaints rather than a count of them4 / 4
DDigital Presence & Authority
6/25
D1 Website trust & experienceObservedCWV fail · no bar numbers on bios · no fee statement · privacy policy · no disclaimer · fresh content1.5 / 7
D2 Search authorityAhrefs · 2026-09-16DR 25 → 68th pct of 22-firm cohort (median 19) 2/3 · 441 referring domains, 9th pct 0/2 · 22 organic keywords / 34 visits·mo, 9th pct 0/2 · brand demand 0/1 (pending)2 / 8
D3 Local presenceGoogle3 operational Google Business Profile listings with reviews · profile completeness, NAP consistency across citations and local-pack rank not yet measured (4 of 5 pts still available)1 / 5
D4 Content, E-E-A-T & schemaAhrefs · 2026-09-16content 0/2 · JSON-LD detected 1/1 · earned media 0/11 / 5
EAccess & Responsiveness
1/15
E1 Free consult & fee transparencyObservedFree consultation · fee model not published · the fee percentage itself is not published1 / 6
E3 Languages & accessibilityObservedEnglish0 / 4
E4 AvailabilityObservedno availability published0 / 5
Next automated re-check: Oct 1, 2026 · Cohort: Buffalo x Personal Injury (24 firms measured)How the score works →

Digital presence snapshot

Pillar D signals, re-measured monthly. Paid advertising is not scored.

Domain authority
25· 65th percentile
441 ref. domains · cohort median 21 · Ahrefs rank 6.2M
Observed · Ahrefs, 2026-09-16
Trust pages
2 / 2
privacy policy · blog
Observed
Core Web Vitals
Failmobile
Performance 63
Observed · PSI, 2026-09-14

Practice areas 1 areas · primary focus highlighted

Personal Injury

Client reviews

4.9
★★★★★
Based on 334 Google reviews · Google Business Profile via Places API. 3 listings, counts summed and rating weighted by count · Quotes below are testimonials published by the firm

Offices 3 locations · main office: Buffalo

Buffalo487 Main St #500, Buffalo, NY 14203, USA
Rochester16 W Main St Ste 745, Rochester, NY 14614, USA
Canandaigua280 S Main St Suite 103, Canandaigua, NY 14424, USA