
Boatman Ricci names 31 people, the largest roster in this ranking by a wide margin, and works from Airport-Pulling Road North with a second Fort Myers office.
Real estate firms handling residential and commercial closings, title insurance and escrow, title defects, condominium and association disputes, and land use. Every firm is checked for a registered entity, a confirmed office and a clean disciplinary record, and ranked on what it publishes about the transaction rather than on outcomes it never has. So far that means Naples, FL.
A firm is worth comparing against the firms somebody could hire instead of it, so every ranking is a city and a practice. Pick the city.

Boatman Ricci names 31 people, the largest roster in this ranking by a wide margin, and works from Airport-Pulling Road North with a second Fort Myers office.

Cheffy Passidomo is the established name in Naples practice and names fifteen attorneys, including both partners in its name, from Fifth Avenue South.

Cona Law works from Airport-Pulling Road North. It publishes none of the trust pages pillar D looks for, no fee terms we could record and none of the stages of a transaction, and it names no attorney on the pages we could reach.
Comparing these firms the way you would compare injury firms will point you at the wrong things. There are no verdicts to weigh, no settlements to add up, and the number most people try to shop on is fixed by the state. What is left is narrower and more useful: what the firm will charge you, what it will do that a title company cannot, and who answers when the closing goes wrong.
Florida is one of a small number of states where the premium for title insurance is set by the state rather than by the company selling it. Section 627.782 of the Florida Statutes requires the Financial Services Commission to adopt a rule "specifying the premium to be charged in this state by title insurers", and every agency charges it. A firm advertising a better price on the policy is either describing something that is not the policy, or describing something it cannot do.
What does vary, and by a lot, is the settlement or closing fee: the charge for handling the file, running the searches, holding the money and clearing the title. That figure is negotiable, it is rarely published, and it is the number to ask for in writing before anybody signs anything. The firms in this directory that publish a flat fee are marked, because publishing it at all is unusual.
Florida licenses title insurance agencies and publishes the register, and a law firm doing title work often is not in it. That is what the statute intends rather than a gap: section 626.8417(4) exempts "attorneys duly admitted to practice law in this state and in good standing with The Florida Bar" from the licensing and appointment requirements that apply to an agency.
So the register can confirm that a firm holds an agency licence and can never establish that one should, and the numbers bear that out. We read the state’s list of every valid business licence in Florida, 2,643 of them held by title agencies, and not one of the twenty firms ranked here appears in it under its own name. That is the exemption working rather than twenty firms cutting a corner, and it is why the licence is published as a fact where we find one and never scored: a test that separates nobody is not a test.
Both can run a title search, issue a commitment, hold the deposit and record the deed. Only one of them can tell you what the contract you signed obliges you to do, negotiate a repair after an inspection, argue about a defect the search turned up, or represent you if the other side walks away. A title company handling a dispute is practising law without a licence, and the moment a file stops being routine is the moment that distinction starts to matter.
It is also why this directory lists law firms and not title companies, even where the title company has more reviews and a nicer office. Several of the highest rated businesses a search for a real estate lawyer returns in these markets are title agencies, and every one of them was left out.
Four questions, and the answers are short. What is your fee for this closing, in dollars, in writing. Who holds the escrow, and at which bank. Which underwriter will issue the policy. And who calls me if the survey, the lien search or the association estoppel comes back wrong, which is the question that separates a firm from a file number.